Back to School Resources

Academic Perfectionism

9 min read

For students with RSD, perfectionism isn't about high standards - it's about fear. Understanding the connection between rejection sensitivity and academic perfectionism can help break the cycle of avoidance, procrastination, and underachievement.

The RSD-Perfectionism Connection

Students with RSD often develop perfectionism as a protective strategy:

"If I'm perfect, no one can criticise me"

"If I don't try, I can't fail"

"If it's not perfect, it's not worth submitting"

"If I control everything, I can prevent rejection"

The Perfectionism Paradox

This creates a paradox: the fear of failure leads to behaviours that increase the likelihood of failure.

Working so hard on one assignment that others don't get done
Starting over repeatedly rather than improving what exists
Spending hours on minor details while missing main points
Not submitting work because it's "not ready"
Refusing to attempt tasks where success isn't guaranteed

Types of Academic Perfectionism

The Achiever

Some students with RSD channel their fear into overwork:

  • Excessive time spent on every assignment
  • Devastation over anything less than perfect grades
  • Burnout from unsustainable effort levels
  • Anxiety that increases with academic success
  • Inability to prioritise (everything must be perfect)

The Avoider

Others avoid academic tasks entirely:

  • Procrastination until it's "too late to do well"
  • Not submitting work at all
  • Choosing easy classes to guarantee success
  • Dropping out of activities where they might not excel
  • Creating external excuses for not performing

The Controller

Some try to control their environment:

  • Excessive need for clarity before starting
  • Inability to work without perfect conditions
  • Asking repeated questions to avoid ambiguity
  • Rigid routines that, if disrupted, prevent work
  • Conflict with group members who don't meet standards

How Teachers Can Help

Reframe Failure

Explicitly teach that mistakes are learning opportunities
Share your own learning failures and what you gained
Celebrate "productive failures" - mistakes that taught something
Avoid language that equates grades with worth

Growth Mindset Language

Fixed mindset:

  • "You're so smart!"
  • "You got it wrong"
  • "This should be easy for you"
  • "You're not trying hard enough"

Growth mindset:

  • "You worked hard on that!"
  • "Not yet - here's what to try"
  • "This is challenging - let's break it down"
  • "What strategy could help?"

Structure for Success

  • Chunked assignments

    Break large projects into graded stages

  • Clear rubrics

    Remove ambiguity about expectations

  • Process grades

    Grade effort and process, not just outcomes

  • Revision opportunities

    Remove fear of first attempts

Manage Comparison

  • Avoid public ranking or display of grades
  • Don't compare students to each other
  • Emphasise individual progress over absolute performance
  • Be careful with competitive activities

How Parents Can Help

At Home

  • 1
    Model imperfection

    Let them see you make and recover from mistakes

  • 2
    Praise process

    Effort, strategies, and learning, not outcomes

  • 3
    Set realistic expectations

    Not every assignment needs their best work

  • 4
    Accept "good enough"

    Sometimes finishing is more important than perfecting

Conversations to Have

  • Instead of "What grade did you get?"

    "What did you learn?"

  • Instead of "Was it easy?"

    "What was challenging?"

  • Instead of "Why didn't you..."

    "What will you try next time?"

  • Regardless of outcome:

    "I'm proud of how you handled that"

When They're Stuck

Help them start imperfectly rather than not starting
Set time limits: "Give this 30 minutes of your best effort"
Normalise: "Most people find this hard at first"
Focus on next steps, not fixing what's "wrong"

The 80% Rule

Help your child understand that in most situations, 80% effort yields better results than 100% effort:

  • The last 20% takes 80% of the time
  • Perfectionism on one task steals from others
  • "Good enough" submitted beats "perfect" not submitted
  • Learning comes from completion, not perfection

Strategies for Students

Getting Started

  • Five-minute starts

    Commit to just 5 minutes, then decide whether to continue

  • Worst first draft

    Write the worst possible version first

  • Body-doubling

    Work alongside someone else for accountability

  • Environment change

    Start somewhere different to break the block

Managing Standards

  • Grade the task

    Decide what grade of effort it deserves before starting

  • Time boxing

    Set a fixed time, submit whatever you have

  • Good enough criteria

    Define "done" before starting

  • One revision rule

    Allow yourself exactly one revision

Handling Mistakes

  • Name the thinking

    "My brain is telling me this is a disaster"

  • Perspective check

    "Will this matter in a week? A year?"

  • Find the learning

    "What did this teach me?"

  • Remember

    One grade doesn't define you

When to Seek Additional Help

Consider professional support if perfectionism is causing:

Significant academic underperformance
School avoidance or refusal
Anxiety or depression symptoms
Physical symptoms (headaches, stomach aches, sleep issues)
Social withdrawal
Self-harm or suicidal thoughts

Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) can be particularly effective for perfectionism, helping students challenge unhelpful thinking patterns and develop healthier academic habits.

The Goal

The goal isn't to eliminate high standards - it's to help students develop healthy striving instead of fear-driven perfectionism. Healthy strivers set high but achievable goals, learn from setbacks, and don't tie their self-worth to perfect outcomes. They can push themselves without crushing themselves.